Quote:
I have read the Piper/Trojan blurb, see what they are saying and would say they are talking about "time-lines". Piper filters are and always have been "Race" filters and they change them like all race parts for every race. The K&N is, mostly, a re-usable road filter design.
Pipercross filters are washable and re-oilable just like K&N so are not a 'throw away' race item at all. They offer race only filters for some models and road/race filters for others. The Buell item is a road filter so have thicker and denser foam and also dual layers of varying density.
Quote:
What they do not say is that the Piper is a "flat surface" design were as the OEM (which is good) and the K&N (much better) are a flutted design.
That isn't actually correct. The advantage of dense foam filters such as Pipercross is that they have a much larger surface area than either paper or cloth types and are certainly not flat surface. This means that they resist clogging for much longer than cloth or paper types. Filter performance measured on brand new filters is similar, but measure a filter with 5000 miles use and the resulst will be much more telling, with stock filters coming out very badly in comparison to K&N or Pipercross.
Pipercross have been making performance filters for years and supply some of the top names in racing and OE filters for people like Triumph, so are just as good as K&N (and are of course British

).
Lastly, when we first approached Pipercross to make a Buell fitment we supplied them with a stock and a K&N filter. Their brief was to make a filtrer that flowed better than either and that was suitable for prolonged road use. They have very sophisticated flow benches and measuring equipment and are happy that they have achieved both design briefs.
Both K&N and Pipercross work extremely well so you have a choice of two excellent products. If you have a particular brand loyalty then go for that one. You won't be disappointed with either of them.